It was a little difficult to find in the little mall as their name didn't stand out among all of the other neon signs but that wouldn't deter me from returning. Delivery & Pickup Options - 458 reviews of Anthony & Mario's Broadway Pizzeria 'i ordered for delivery a Baked Ziti,with marinara sauce, 10 garlic knots and a side salad-plus a drink all for under 11, (10 minumum) they had it to me within 20 minutes and it was hot & tasty. Be prepared to get your pizza to go if it is busy and there is no seating room. As others have stated, it's a small place, I think I remember 6 tables that seat 4 each. Open late each night, the restaurant is also perfect for a post-theater dinner, a light bite at the antipasto bar, or cocktails and dessert. Fiorello's is a great spot for pre-theater dining. Since I ordered my pizza to go, I didn't get to try a cold beer on tap. Cafe Fiorello is an institution across the street from Lincoln Center, serving breakfast, lunch, dinner and brunch on the weekends. Flavor was spot on and I wouldn't change a thing. Ordered a pepperoni and green olive and it was fantastic. I ended up getting the smaller pizza and was able to save half for the next night. Sounded like they had a two sizes of pizza, large (too much for myself) and not so large (good for one). Person at the counter was helpful and cheerful and helped me with some questions since I had not been there before. Was a little worried about getting a pizza since their website stated they closed. It was a few minutes down the road so I decided to give it a try.
We have beer on tap for you to enjoy with your pizza.